Why Hydrogen Vehicles Lag Behind Electric Vehicles as a Viable Environmental Option

Hydrogen vehicles are often touted as a promising alternative to electric vehicles, but the reality is that they lag far behind in terms of practicality and cost-effectiveness. It's not that hydrogen vehicles are entirely impractical; rather, they are significantly less viable compared to their electric counterparts.

Historical Context and Adoption

Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles have been around almost as long as the Apollo program, which means they have been in development for at least 60 years. Despite this long history, hydrogen fuel cell vehicles have not gained substantial traction in the market. There is lots of hype about these vehicles, but even after 30 years of talk, the number of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles ever built is less than 100,000. In contrast, battery electric vehicles (BEVs) are selling more than ever, with a single week's sales surpassing the total number of fuel cell vehicles ever sold.

Cost and Infrastructure Challenges

One of the primary reasons why hydrogen vehicles are less viable is the cost. Producing and distributing hydrogen is significantly more expensive than other forms of fuelling your vehicle. Hydrogen requires an extensive distribution network of trucks, storage tanks, and delivery points, which adds to the overall cost. Furthermore, hydrogen cars are far more expensive to manufacture than conventional internal combustion engine (ICE) or electric vehicles (EVs).

Technical and Safety Issues

From a technical standpoint, hydrogen fuel cells are expensive to make and maintain. They also face challenges in terms of efficiency and practicality. Hydrogen is not just expensive to produce; it is also difficult to handle safely. The gas is highly explosive and requires specialized couplings and pipework. It must be stored at extremely high pressures, which adds to the complexity and cost of the system.

Environmental and Economic Considerations

While hydrogen can be a clean fuel source if produced from renewable energy, its overall environmental impact is currently less favorable compared to electric vehicles. The energy density of hydrogen is lower than that of gasoline, which means it requires more energy to produce and transport. Additionally, there is no comprehensive hydrogen fueling infrastructure, especially in the USA and most countries around the world.

Comparison with Electric Vehicles

Electric vehicles (EVs) have several advantages over hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. In terms of ownership costs, EVs are generally cheaper to own than ICE vehicles due to lower maintenance and operational costs. EVs have become increasingly cost-effective, with advancements in battery technology and the falling price of batteries. Moreover, electric vehicles do not suffer from the same emission issues as modified ICEs, which produce NOX emissions and other pollutants.

Conclusion

While hydrogen vehicles have potential, they currently lag behind electric vehicles in terms of practicality, cost-effectiveness, and infrastructure. Extracting, producing, and transporting hydrogen is costly and complex. The lack of a comprehensive refueling infrastructure makes hydrogen vehicles less viable. For now, electric vehicles offer a more practical and cost-effective solution for environmentally conscious consumers.

For a deeper dive into the pros and cons of hydrogen and electric vehicles, check out my Quora Profile.