Why Arent There Protests in India Despite Hundreds of Child Deaths in Gorakhpur?

Introduction

The recent incidents of hundreds of children dying in Gorakhpur and now Farrukhabad, Uttar Pradesh, have raised significant questions about the state of healthcare and public responsiveness in India. Despite the tragedy, there has been a notable absence of large-scale protests and national media coverage. This article aims to delve into the reasons behind this dearth of protests, highlighting the social, political, and procedural factors at play.

Selective Outrage and Class Divides

India exhibits a troubling trend of selective outrage based on class. While middle-class voices are often heard and recognized, the plight of the poorest children remains overlooked. Events such as the deaths in Gorakhpur and now Farrukhabad illustrate this disconnect. The victims are often the poorest of the poor, and their cries for help do not garner the same level of attention and mobilization as those from more privileged backgrounds.

A Missed Opportunity for Collective Action

The victimized parents had a unique chance to unite and demand justice through a solidarity march. Instead, it was the voice of children from Udaipur that was heard, carrying placards and addressing the President of India and the government. These children demanded protection, preventive measures, and a thorough investigation. However, national media largely ignored their protest, while local media picked up the story.

Understanding Public Perception of Protests

The average apolitical Indian often views protests with skepticism, believing that nothing will change as a result. This apathy is reinforced by the belief that such incidents occur in remote areas and not in major cities like Mumbai or Delhi. Additionally, the fear of opposition and the manipulation of social media to discredit such movements serves to further dampen the chances of widespread protest.

Political Complexities and Apathy

The current political climate in Uttar Pradesh presents another barrier to large-scale protests. The opposition party, Samajwadi Party, is currently in a precarious position and cannot afford to challenge the existing system openly. This leaves little room for meaningful and large-scale opposition to the current government, even in the face of such egregious lapses in public health.

Conclusion

The silence surrounding hundreds of child deaths in Gorakhpur and now Farrukhabad is a reflection of deep-seated issues such as class divides, general public apathy, and political complexities. While individual cases such as the child protests offer hope, a sustained and effective movement requires addressing these systemic issues head-on.

Note: This article emphasizes the importance of collective action and awareness in addressing public health crises in India. It is crucial for citizens to mobilize and demand justice, both through direct action and sustained advocacy.