Which is Better for Drywall Finishing: Mesh Tape or Paper Tape?

When it comes to finishing drywall, two common materials are often compared: mesh tape and paper tape. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, and the choice between them often depends on the skill level of the installer and the specific requirements of the project.

Overview of Mesh Tape and Paper Tape

Making the decision between mesh and paper tape largely depends on the installer's proficiency and the specific needs of the job. Mesh tape is easier to use, particularly for beginners, and can be used for both repairs and finishing. Some practitioners even wets the paper tape to help with application, applying just enough to dampen it without compromising its integrity.

For best results, careful application techniques are essential. Ensure that you do not press too hard when overcoating the tape, as this can cause the compound underneath to be squeezed out, leading to poor adherence to the drywall.

Tape and Mud: Finishing Techniques

Tape and mud are fundamental components of the drywall finishing process. The use of corner bead is essential for protecting corners from damage, especially when moving heavy items. For most repairs, mesh tape is the preferred choice, but it can also be used for finishing if done correctly.

A professional approach is strongly recommended for both mesh and paper tape installations. Construction professionals choose specific materials and tools for a reason, and deviating from established practices can lead to poorer outcomes. The commonly cited adage, "If everyone does it one way and you decide to do it your way, you'll find out why everyone does it the other way," underscores the importance of adhering to proven techniques.

Choosing the Right Tape for Your Project

For more experienced professionals, paper tape is generally the preferred choice. It is stronger and offers fewer chances of sanding through to the tape, leading to a smoother and more professional finish. The three-coat taping process for drywall is fundamental and involves an embedded coat, a fill coat, and a final top-coat or skim. Each coat should be allowed to dry thoroughly before applying additional coats.

If you are new to drywall installation, starting with mesh tape can be less challenging and can help in reducing issues such as bubbles and blisters that are common with paper tape. However, for angles and tapered seams, paper tape is typically the better choice. It is highly recommended to seek professional assistance for your first drywall job to ensure a professional-looking finish.

An important consideration for beginners is that even with mesh tape, the finishing process can be messy and dusty. It may take some time to master the technique of applying the tape and the necessary coats of mud to achieve a smooth and professional-looking finish. The learning curve with paper tape can be even steeper, but the results are often worth the extra effort for a truly professional finish.

Conclusion

Both mesh tape and paper tape have their place in drywall finishing. Mesh tape is a practical choice for beginners and for specific applications, while paper tape offers superior strength and a smoother finish for more experienced professionals. The best approach is to learn from professionals, observe established best practices, and make an informed choice based on your skill level and the project requirements.

Key Points

Mesh tape and paper tape both have their advantages and disadvantages Mesh tape is easier to use and suitable for repairs, while paper tape is stronger and better for finishing A professional approach is recommended for both types of tape The three-coat process is essential for a smooth and professional finish