Understanding the Classification Controversies Surrounding Hillary Clinton’s Email Server

There has been a persistent misunderstanding regarding the classification of Hillary Clinton’s email server. It is a common misconception that the entire server itself was deemed classified. However, the reality is more nuanced. During the investigation, specific emails on the server were found to contain classified information rather than the server itself.

Why Emails Were Deemed Classified

The process of determining which emails were classified was conducted after the initial investigation of the server. This decision was made based on the content of the emails, not the classification of the server itself. For instance, discussions that hinted at or confirmed the existence of the drone strike program were flagged as containing classified information.

The Context of the Drone Strike Program

The drone strike program was widely known at the time, but the government had not officially acknowledged its existence. Any information that directly confirmed the program's operations would have been considered sensitive and classified. Therefore, emails discussing the drone strike program were deemed classified because they provided evidence of the program's existence and operations.

The Impact of Classified Information

The classification of the information in the emails, rather than the emails themselves, had significant implications. Public knowledge of the drone strike program could potentially compromise the program's operations and its future mission. This is why the existence of the emails was classified, rather than their specific content.

Why the Server Itself Was Not Classified

It is crucial to understand that the server itself was not classified. The server was a personal computer used by Hillary Clinton whilst serving as the U.S. Secretary of State. Its classification was only related to the emails stored on it and the information contained within those emails.

The Process of Review and Classification

The process involved a thorough review of each email on the server. Analysts assessed the content of each email to determine if it contained any information that would be considered classified. This review helped to identify emails that, when released, could risk national security or diplomatic relations. The decision to classify the content of these emails was based on the potential damage or impact if the information were to be made public.

Importance of Context in Classification

The context under which the information was discussed is crucial in determining whether it should be classified. In the case of the drone strike program, the discussion itself represented sensitive information that could confirm or deny the existence of the program. This context is what led to the classification of the emails rather than the server.

Conclusion

The classification of Hillary Clinton’s email server during the investigation was a complex issue with significant security implications. It is important to understand that the server itself was not classified, but the emails it contained were deemed to have classified information. The decision to classify the information was based on the potential damage to national security and diplomatic operations, not on the server's status.

Understanding these nuances is crucial for avoiding misinformation and ensuring a proper evaluation of the situation. The process of classifying information remains a delicate and important aspect of government operations, ensuring the protection of national security and sensitive diplomatic operations.