The Right of Existence: Debunking the Binary View on Jewish States

In the complex and often contentious discussions surrounding global politics, one particular issue has garnered significant attention: the right of Jewish states to exist. Contrary to prevailing narratives, the legitimacy of Jewish states is not a marginal or arbitrary issue. It is a matter of equal rights, religious diversity, and the shared human experience.

Redefining the Foundation of Jewish States

The notion that the founding fathers of Israel were not religious but atheists is a common misconception. While there exist diverse beliefs within the secular and religious Jewish communities, the establishment of Israel was not solely based on religious grounds. Rather, it is a complex blend of historical, cultural, and political factors. The idea that Israel is not 'Jewish enough' due to its secular foundation is a superficial and misleading argument. The core identity of the state revolves around the collective heritage, shared history, and aspirations of a people.

Is Israel an Outlier?

The assertion that the existence of Jewish states is outrageous in the context of Christian and Muslim countries is a reflection of a broader issue. It highlights the paradoxical nature of global politics: while it is commonplace for Christian and Muslim states to coexist and acknowledge each other's right to exist, the same is not always extended to Jewish states. This selective recognition often stems from a deeper, ingrained historical and cultural bias.

The premise that religion provides a basis for exclusive statehood is flawed. It disregards the fact that people are people, and they deserve equal rights regardless of their faith or lack thereof. The analogy of a "X faith nation" versus an "Abdul-Karim nation" effectively exposes the absurdity of such exclusivity. In a world diverse in culture and belief, it is unjust to grant or deny statehood based on one's religious affiliation.

Equitable Rights and Reformulating the Debate

The argument against Jewish states often simplifies the complex human rights and land issues in the Middle East. It is a fundamental observation that in a place like Palestine, Jews, Muslims, Christians, and non-believers alike should have the right to live in peace, equality, and safety. The accusations of land theft and illegal evictions do not only affect one group but are part of a larger narrative of human rights violations.

The call to stop treating Jewish states as an outlier is not mere support for their existence. It is a demand for a fair and equitable international system that respects the rights of all peoples. The notion that only certain groups have the 'right to exist' is both discriminatory and counterproductive. A more inclusive and just approach is necessary to address the conflicts in the region.

A Call for Global Equity

The core of this debate centers on the binary view of existence, which unfairly disallows Jewish states due to historical and cultural biases. It is time to reformulate the discourse to focus on mutual respect, shared rights, and the principles of human dignity. The international community must recognize that Jewish states, just like any other states, have the right to exist and thrive, regardless of religious or cultural affiliations.

Shalom and Toda Rabba.