The Impact of Killing Edwin in Baldur's Gate 1 on Your Character's Journey to Baldur's Gate 2

When playing games like Baldur's Gate 1, making crucial decisions can significantly alter the narrative and gameplay experience. One such decision involves Edwin, the mage character. This article explores whether killing Edwin in Baldur's Gate 1 and exporting your character to Baldur's Gate 2 is still viable and whether such an action has any significant impact on your character's journey.

What Happens if You Kill Edwin in Baldur's Gate 1?

It is indeed possible to kill Edwin in Baldur's Gate 1. After completing the main quest involving Edwin, you can potentially kill him if you choose a specific course of action. However, it is worth noting that even if you do kill him, Edwin will still come back to life.

What's more, you have the option to gloss over his murder if you choose to meet him in Amn later in the game. Interestingly, Edwin is still willing to join your party even after you admit to his murder. This flexibility in the game's story and character interactions makes it less impactful than one might initially assume.

Will Killing Edwin Affect Your Character when Exported to Baldur's Gate 2?

One might wonder if killing Edwin in Baldur's Gate 1 will have any repercussions when you export your character to Baldur's Gate 2. Surprisingly, it doesn't. When you meet Edwin in the second game, he appears as usual, and his response indicates that the game doesn't remember your past actions.

In Baldur's Gate 2, you can encounter Edwin in Amn and engage in a dialogue where he says, "You might have killed me but it doesn't matter." Upon further conversation, he will remember you and act as if you're a stranger, which can add an element of surprise and refreshment to the storyline. Even if you've already killed him in the first game, affecting his memory serves as a way to create a fresh start for your character in the second installment.

The Consequences and Benefits of Exporting Your Character

Exporting your character from Baldur's Gate 1 to Baldur's Gate 2 involves a few advantages and trade-offs. When you export your character, you receive a few items and some elevated character stats. This can be beneficial but should not be the primary reason for leveraging this feature.

On the one hand, the items and stats you carry over can provide an initial advantage. However, it is crucial to understand that your actions in Baldur's Gate 1 do not significantly alter the gameplay experience in Baldur's Gate 2. The narrative and quests in the second game are largely unaffected by your choices in the first game. Therefore, killing Edwin in Baldur's Gate 1 and then exporting your character to the second game might not result in significant changes to your journey in Baldur's Gate 2.

This feature is more about banking on the items and stats that you have earned so far rather than throwing away valuable in-game resources for the sake of narrative consistency. It is important to weigh the pros and cons before deciding to export your character and make informed decisions based on your playstyle and preferences.

Conclusion

Ultimately, killing Edwin in Baldur's Gate 1 and exporting your character to Baldur's Gate 2 is a relatively safe decision. While it might seem like a significant narrative change, the game's mechanics are designed to keep your past actions in the first game from significantly impacting the second. The decision to kill Edwin or any other character in the first game should be based on your current playstyle and the type of storyline you enjoy, rather than potential long-term impact on your journey in the second game.

So, if you're feeling adventurous or simply want to gain a few items and stats, go ahead and kill away. But remember, in the grand scheme of things, your actions won't drastically alter the outcome of your adventure in Baldur's Gate 2! Enjoy your gameplay and let the magic of RPGs guide your journey!