Should You Buy an Older MacBook Pro or a New 2019 Model?

The choice between purchasing an older generation MacBook Pro and a brand new 2019 model depends on several factors, including your budget, performance needs, and personal preferences. Let's dive into some surprising facts that can help you make an informed decision.

Performance and Configuration

Contrary to popular belief, the processors in older MacBook Pros can often outperform the newer models, especially if you opt for a high-end configuration from a few years back. The thermal design and cooling capabilities of some older MacBooks were superior, allowing for better sustained performance.

While newer MacBook Pros feature faster storage and memory, the difference in real-world usage may not be as dramatic as you might expect. Older SSDs have become remarkably quick, and the impact on most everyday tasks is negligible.

Battery Life and Repairability

Battery life is a critical factor to consider, with newer MacBook Pros generally offering better endurance. However, with proper maintenance and replacement, you can extend the lifespan of an older battery significantly. Repairability is a significant advantage of older MacBook Pros. They feature less soldered components and more modular designs, making it easier and more cost-effective to replace individual parts like the keyboard, display, or storage.

Design and Aesthetics

The design and aesthetics of newer MacBook Pros are undoubtedly sleeker and more modern. However, if you prioritize functionality over form, an older model may still serve you well, especially if you can find one in excellent condition.

Personal Experience and Upgrades

My personal experience with a 2017 MacBook Pro Touch Bar has been quite positive. It runs great, with no service issues, a good battery, and no reason to upgrade. I would consider myself a power user to some degree. I also use Windows 11 on Parallels, and it works great. When it does come time for an upgrade, I'll be moving up to a 2019 model—the newest one available with the Touch Bar.

Ultimately, the decision hinges on your specific needs and budget. An older MacBook Pro, with strategic upgrades, can offer outstanding value. A brand new 2019 model, on the other hand, will provide the latest features and a longer lifespan.

Conclusion: The choice between an older MacBook Pro and a new 2019 model depends on your individual circumstances. Weigh your budget, performance needs, and personal preferences to make an informed decision that fits your unique requirements.