Has Anyone Had a Stolen Firearm Returned by Police?

Stolen Firearm Returns: A Personal Story

Back in 2001, I lost my Smith and Wesson 9mm handgun in a burglary. It was quite the loss, and even after so much time, I never imagined that my firearm would see the light of day again. Fast forward to a random day in 2018, and guess who called me out of the blue? My local police department. They had my stolen 9mm and were happy to return it to me after 17 years. It was truly a miracle.

However, not all experiences are as fortunate. Another person shared a similar experience but with a less happy ending. Their firearms were stolen during a burglary, and they were later illegally confiscated by police. Despite a judge ordering the return, the guns had disappeared. This highlights the variability of police department response to theft and recovery.

On the other hand, some situations can be resolved quite effectively. For example, in Garland, Texas, local police recovered all stolen firearms within 24 hours, including a high-end shotgun. The police department there is recognized for their prompt and efficient handling of such cases. This underscores the importance of a well-coordinated and dedicated team when it comes to recovering stolen firearms.

Police Policy on Returning Stolen Firearms

The Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department, like many other agencies, has strict policies regarding the return of stolen firearms. According to their practice, only low-cost firearms, commonly referred to as "Saturday night specials," are destroyed. This is done once a year to ensure that these guns are not available on the black market. More expensive firearms are typically sold to licensed dealers.

It is worth noting that this practice is not universal. Police departments vary in their approach, and it is always best to check with the local authorities if you are dealing with a stolen firearm. If you possess a legally owned and legally possessed firearm, the police have no right to withhold it beyond the need for evidence. Once the evidence is no longer required, the firearm should be returned.

Police Practices and Gun Ownership Rights

Police officers, for the most part, are conservative in their views and uphold the right of law-abiding citizens to possess firearms. However, the handling of stolen firearms and their return can be quite challenging. As a general rule, if you are aware that your firearm has been recovered and you can prove ownership, you have the right to request its return once the evidence period is over.

However, the process is far from straightforward. Many police departments, including the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department, have policies that allow them to destroy a firearm if it is not returned in a timely manner, even if you are the rightful owner. It is therefore advisable to stay persistent and follow up regularly. The police can only go so far in their assistance, but persistence can yield results.