Exploring LINQ-like Functional Programming in C: Current Status and Future Prospects

r r

As of the last update in August 2023, there has not been a formal proposal to add a LINQ-like facility to the C standard library. However, there has been ongoing discussion within the C community about improving the language's capabilities for functional programming and range-based operations. This reflects a broader interest in enhancing C's expressiveness and conciseness, aligning with the spirit of LINQ (Language Integrated Query), which is prevalent in other languages like C# and .NET.

r r

Current Implementations and Libraries

r r

Several libraries have been developed to provide similar functionality to LINQ, enabling more expressive and concise operations on collections by using ranges and views. One notable example is Range-v3, which offers a rich set of functionalities for working with ranges in C .

r r

The C20 standard introduced ranges into the standard library, offering some LINQ-like capabilities. These features allow for more functional-style programming with algorithms that can be composed in a more readable way. This is a significant step towards making C more suitable for functional programming paradigms.

r r

Challenges and Limitations

r r

The current implementation of the C standard library tends to run much leaner and more conservative than those of languages like Java, C#, or Python. One of the defining features of LINQ is its runtime-reflection-based nature, which can be complex and sometimes against the grain of C's design principle of simplicity and efficiency. However, this does not mean that there are no other options available.

r r

Boost is a highly respected library in the C community, providing numerous options for DSL (Domain-Specific Language) parsers, generators, and accessors. While these do not directly replicate LINQ, they offer rich functionality for existing types. Moreover, there are several non-standard but portable and permissive-license options available for working with specific data stores.

r r

Proposed and Accepted Features

r r

There have been a few proposals and accepted features in C17 that provide aspects of structured views and table selectors. These proposals are not as comprehensive as a single LINQ-like library but offer helpful functionality in certain scenarios. Two Technical Specifications (TS) and various accepted features are already in place, providing a foundation for more advanced functional programming in C.

r r

Future Expectations

r r

Future C standards may continue to evolve in this direction. Official inclusion of a LINQ-like feature would depend on proposals being made, discussed, and accepted by the standards committee. Keeping an eye on the discussions from the C standards committee (WG21) and related forums can provide valuable insights into the future of C and its enhancements.

r r

Conclusion

r r

While a direct LINQ-like facility in the C standard library has not been established, the landscape of C community libraries and standards is continuously evolving. By leveraging libraries like Range-v3 and staying informed about the ongoing discussions in the C standards committee, developers can harness the power of functional programming in their C code bases.