Choosing Between the New MacBook Pro M1 16GB and an Intel i9 12th Gen Desktop for Video Editing and Coding

When considering an upgrade to your computer for intensive tasks like video editing and coding, the new MacBook Pro M1 16GB and an Intel i9 12th Gen desktop with 32GB RAM present compelling options. Both platforms have their strengths, but which one is better for your specific needs?

Performance Considerations: MacBook Pro M1 vs. Intel i9 Desktop

MacBook Pro M1 16GB

For the entry-level M1 MacBook Pro or even the M1 Air, the comparison is stark when you look at the Intel i9 12th Gen desktop. The Core i9 desktop CPU is comparable to the high-end M1 Ultra and M1 Max, suggesting significant performance parity. However, there's a significant cost-benefit analysis to consider.

Opting for the M1 Max Mac Studio at $1,999, you get a powerhouse of a machine with top-of-the-line performance for that price point. This makes the M1 Max Mac Studio a fantastic value proposition. Believe it or not, even a custom-built PC costing around $1,999, including the CPU, SSD, RAM, GPU, motherboard, and casing, won't match the M1 Max in terms of performance.

Intel i9 12th Gen Desktop

The Intel i9 12th Gen desktop offers excellent performance for your needs, especially when combined with 32GB of RAM. However, it requires a different level of setup, including a separate graphics card, which could further increase the cost. The desktop's upgradeability is another factor, as you can add more RAM or a faster SSD down the line, whereas the Mac's RAM is not upgradeable once you reach the 16GB threshold.

Portability and Usability

Portability

If you need to work on the go, the MacBook Pro M1 offers unparalleled portability. Its sleek design and long battery life make it an excellent choice for on-the-go projects. However, if you're willing to set up a stationary work environment, the Intel i9 desktop provides a more powerful and flexible setup. The desktop can be easily moved if needed but often requires more space.

Usability

The MacBooks' unified 16GB of RAM feels like having 32GB in Windows systems. This is a significant advantage, especially if you're looking for a seamless all-around experience. Additionally, the DCI-P3 calibrated screen offers excellent color accuracy, which is crucial for video editing. The MacBook Pro is also exceptionally quiet, much appreciated when you're working intensely on a project or unwinding with a movie.

Specialized Use Cases

Video Editing

For video editing, the 16GB of RAM in the MacBook Pro M1 might feel a bit stingy, especially for 4K or 8K work. The desktop, on the other hand, can be upgraded to 64GB of RAM for the price of a mouse. If you're on the fence about the Pro or Air models, the Air version is often chosen for its lightweight and silent operation, along with the absence of the Touch Bar, which some find annoying.

Coding

For coding, the Mac is still the better option. Xcode, the primary development environment for macOS and iOS apps, runs more seamlessly on a Mac. Additionally, the ability to test on actual hardware is crucial. The new M1 machines can run both iOS and Android apps, Linux, and even Windows, making them incredibly flexible. This versatility is a major advantage for coding.

Summary

Both the new MacBook Pro M1 16GB and an Intel i9 12th Gen desktop offer powerful options, but the choice depends on your specific needs. If you prioritize portability, battery life, and the all-around experience, the MacBook Pro M1 16GB is a great choice, especially for coding and video editing. If you prefer a more powerful desktop setup with more flexibilities and upgradeability, the Intel i9 12th Gen desktop with 32GB of RAM might be the better choice.

Conclusion

When it comes to upgrading your computer for video editing and coding, the decision between the new MacBook Pro M1 16GB and an Intel i9 12th Gen desktop narrows down to your specific needs and preferences. Both platforms have their strengths, and the right choice will depend on whether you value portability, flexibility, or raw power.