Can a Skeptic or Atheist Believe in Tarot?

Is it possible for a skeptic or an atheist to engage with and potentially embrace tarot? This article explores the intersection between skepticism, atheism, and the mystical symbolism of tarot cards.

Approaching Tarot with Skepticism

The skeptic’s approach to tarot, such as myself, is often marked by a healthy dose of skepticism. While I may read tarot, I maintain a level of skepticism regarding its fortune-telling capabilities. Skepticism itself isn't incompatible with the practice; after all, you don't have to believe in something to experiment with it. Studying tarot can be a rich and enlightening journey, offering insights into culture, art, history, mythology, and semiotics.

Furthermore, exploring tarot can be educational. In my view, it's almost like a liberal arts course. Even if the reading itself is not to everyone's liking, it still provides a valuable perspective on the principles underlying divination.

However, it would be a disservice to either condemn or confirm tarot reading through the lens of rational justification. Some diehard skeptics may find this idea frustrating, but it's important to remember that their own skepticism deserves skepticism as well. Everyone has biases; it's crucial to question them and remain open-minded.

My Perspective: A Belief in Richly Symbolic Randomness

I identify as both a skeptic and an atheist. Yet, I do have a certain level of belief in tarot. I see tarot and other methods of divination as embodying the principle of 'richly symbolic randomness.' This principle involves presenting readers and clients with a rich and emotionally powerful array of imagery. Each card offers a range of meanings that can be personally relevant and inspiring, encouraging new insights.

Does this mean tarot can predict the future? Perhaps, but to a limited extent. As Russell Hoban observed, those who seek their fortunes are often the ones whose outcomes are most predictable. The tarot card reader and client must work together to interpret the symbolism and find personal meaning in the cards, rather than expecting a definitive prediction.

Understanding Skepticism and Atheism in the Context of Tarot

Athiesm, the term, is simple: it denotes the absence of belief in God. It doesn’t make claims on other matters, so there’s no point in conflating atheism with skepticism when discussing tarot.

Skepticism, on the other hand, can range from scientific to philosophical. Many skeptics use their analytical tools to approach tarot readings, keeping an open mind while questioning the claims made about their predictive accuracy. A good skeptic will:

Conduct a detailed and critical examination Seek alternative explanations Assess if the principle underlying tarot has a rational basis

Personally, I’ve seen tarot readings and found them to be overly vague and lacking in substantive meaning, which reinforces my skepticism. However, I remain open to being convinced otherwise. The key, as always, is maintaining a balanced and questioning mindset.