Are These Sentences Grammatically Correct?

When considering the grammatical correctness of sentences, it's important to understand the nuances and context in which they are used. Let's examine two sentences provided in the initial question:

The new factory hadnt been built yet.The tablet is the same price as the cell phone.

Understanding Sentence 1

The first sentence, The new factory hadnt been built yet., is grammatically correct. The use of "hadn't" is a contraction of "had not," and it follows the past perfect tense. This tense is used to describe an action that was completed before another action in the past. In this sentence, it accurately conveys that the construction of the factory was not completed before a certain point in the past. While some might suggest adding "when I moved nearby" for clarity, the sentence stands correctly as is.

Understanding Sentence 2

The second sentence, The tablet is the same price as the cell phone., is also grammatically correct, though context and logical consistency are worth noting. While the sentence is colloquially accepted, it logically equates "tablet" with "price," which is not accurate. In essence, the sentence suggests an illogical comparison because a tablet is not price; rather, the price of a tablet should be compared with the price of a cell phone.

Correcting the Logical Flaw

To make the sentence more logical and grammatically correct, several alternative constructions can be used:

The tablet costs the same as the cell price of the tablet is the same as that of the cell price of the tablet and the cell phone are the tablet and the cell phone are priced the tablet is priced the same as the cell tablet and the cell phone are the same in price.

Conclusion

In summary, both sentences are grammatically correct, but the second sentence may be improved for clarity and logical consistency. Understanding these nuances in sentence structure and usage can enhance one's ability to communicate effectively in English.

Further Reading

If you're interested in learning more about sentence structure and grammar in English, consider exploring the following resources:

Purdue Online Writing Lab (OWL)Cambridge Grammar of EnglishBritannica Grammar Blog

Key Takeaways

The new factory hadnt been built yet. is grammatically correct.The tablet is the same price as the cell phone. is colloquially correct but logically awkward; alternatives include: the tablet costs the same as the cell phone, the price of the tablet is the same as that of the cell phone, etc.

References

For more in-depth guidance on English grammar and sentence structure, please refer to:

Chicago Manual of Style (Chicago U Press, 2017)Britannica GrammarStrunk and White’s The Elements of Style (Pearson, 2019)